The Trap of Authenticity

by Mental Health

The trap of authenticity, being ‘the real you’, is the destination of the modern person, pursuing the claim to be put in contact with the singular ‘I.’ Every step on this journey requires working with the push and pull of social influences, personal beliefs, judgments of one’s self against an ideal, all to reach a place where change no longer occurs. Sound strange? Consider how authenticity is often portrayed. Spoken of in near-religious reverence, the authentic person is consistent, doesn’t question who they are or what they do and above all we feel a sense of rightness in their presence.

A Narrow Vision Supporting Judgment

While larger-than-life spiritual leaders are often looked at as being authentic, for the common person it is used almost entirely in juxtaposition to perceived hypocrisy or inconsistency. This use is where the journey of change to the destination of stagnation can be seen as horribly unhelpful. We’re supposed to cherish authenticity, yet celebrate when someone makes a change in their life. A quick addendum will show why this is a problem: the celebration comes when the change is agreed with. As soon as it’s a change that isn’t agreed with, then it’s no longer in the pursuit of authenticity, instead it’s hypocrisy.

Authenticity becomes a cudgel to use on people to tow a perceptual line, named and detailed by the vision of others. This myopic view of a person ignores the interlocking stories of their life. We are not simple creatures, locked into the 1’s and 0’s of a computer program, where we’re either on or off in line with a command. A behavior exists to support the story or narrative a person, in a given context, has identified as important (i.e. a Value). This in no way means other things aren’t important to them, or that there are no other narratives they’re living by.

A single person can be sibling, spouse, child, employee, citizen, human-being, community-member, group-member, etc. Each of these labels, only a handful, come with more narratives attached based on personal history, education, relationships and immediate social context. Those narratives are supporting a host of values, what the person cares about, each triggered by a number of internal and external variables. Our lives are not straight lines and they are not doors being closed or open. We live in a matrix of competing potential identities, all vying for our attention to support behavior that, in a given context, keeps the world making sense to our perception.

Authenticity of Inquiry Not Action

Rather than haranguing ourselves and others about an authenticity that has more to do with judgment and dismissal, we can ask questions. Instead of limiting our interactions to an either of complete agreement or disagreement, we can increase our understanding of how life is working, maybe in ways we hadn’t considered.

  1. Given the context, what value or concern is most important?
  2. How is the person framing what that value means to them in the situation?
  3. With this narrative in mind, how is the person’s behavior supporting what they care about?

These questions move us away from a simplistic view of a life journey and into an appreciation for how many pressures, desires, needs, wants, and influences we’re all trying to juggle in every moment of every day. Authenticity, rather than the trap of a narrow future ideal, can be an inspiration to explore the nuances of our interaction with the many layers of life.

Related Posts


Question Your Feelings, But Don’t Dismiss Them

Question your feelings. This is how we start the exploration of the 2nd Untruth, "always trust your feelings." We will define affect, the wholeness of our emotional experience, labels as a short-hand for communicating a physiological experience to others, and the...


Consequences are Inevitable, Learn From Them

We will instead embrace a deeper appreciation for how our brain/body system works within experience to prepare us for an uncertain future. Ultimately we can learn to accept and even desire to build a capacity for seeing errors and mistakes and consequences as spaces for growth.


Why Hate Feels So Good and What To Do About It

Democracy is a community project and as such, it is only as strong as the virtues of the people who are participating in it. It is only as strong as the social habits we encourage in ourselves and one another. Here we explore the emotion of hate within an understanding of our very human need to shape reality to suit our vision of what we believe it to be or should be, and seeing then how anything that gets in the way of that vision invokes our passions.


Election Thoughts – Voting 2020

Democracy is a Value-based interpersonal construct for guiding human behavior. As such, democracy exists at the intersection of humanity's greatest potential and all our foibles. We can aspire to be the best versions of ourselves that we know to be, but it requires an active engagement, both on the ground through action and also through mindful reflection.


Self-Care Instead of Self-Harm

The stories of our life frame our potential for self-care or self-harm, resilience or fragility, and set us up for an array of behavior that can life affirming or diminishing. The original saying was, "whatever doesn't kill us, makes us stronger" but no more....